Paññāpabhedakathāvaṇṇanā
425. Dhammasabhāvapaṭivedho
M2.77 nāma paññāya āveṇiko sabhāvo , na tenassā koci vibhāgo labbhatīti āha ‘‘ dhammasabhāvapaṭivedhalakkhaṇena tāva ekavidhā ’’ ti .Lujjanapalujjanaṭṭhena loko vuccati vaṭṭaṃ , tappariyāpannatāya loke niyuttā , tattha vā viditāti lokiyā .
Tattha apariyāpannatāya lokato uttarā uttiṇṇāti lokuttarā .
Lokuttarāpi
V2.73 hi maggasampayuttā bhāvetabbā .
Vipassanāpariyāyopi tassā labbhatevāti lokuttara-ggahaṇaṃ na virujjhati .Attānaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā pavattehi saha āsavehīti sāsavā , ārammaṇakaraṇavasenapi natthi etissā āsavāti anāsavā .
Ādi -saddena āsavavippayuttasāsavadukādīnaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo .
Nāmarūpavavatthānavasenāti nāmavavatthānavasena , rūpavavatthānavasena ca .
Paṭhamaṃ nibbānadassanato dassanañca , nissayabhāvato sampayuttā dhammā bhavanti ettha , sayampi vā bhavati uppajjati na nibbānaṃ viya apātubhāvanti bhūmi cāti dassanabhūmi , paṭhamamaggo .
Sesamaggattayaṃ pana yasmā paṭhamamaggena diṭṭhasmiṃyeva dhamme bhāvanāvasena uppajjati , na adiṭṭhapubbaṃ kiñci passati , tasmā bhāvanā ca yathāvuttenatthena bhūmi cāti bhāvanābhūmi .
Tattha paññā dassanabhūmibhāvanābhūmivasena duvidhāti vuttā .
Sutādinirapekkhāya cintāya nibbattā cintāmayā .
Evaṃ sutamayā , bhāvanāmayā ca .
Mayasaddo paccekaṃ sambandhitabbo .
Āye vaḍḍhiyaṃ kosallaṃ āyakosallaṃ , apāye avaḍḍhiyaṃ kosallaṃ apāyakosallaṃ , upāye tassa tassa atthassa nibbattikāraṇe kosallaṃ upāyakosallan ti visuṃ visuṃ kosallapadaṃ sambandhitabbaṃ .
Ajjhattaṃ abhiniveso paṭipajjanaṃ etissāti ajjhattābhinivesā .
Evaṃ bahiddhābhinivesā , ubhayābhinivesā ca veditabbā .
426. Lokiyamaggasampayuttāti lokiyakusalacittuppādesu maggasampayuttā , visesato diṭṭhivisuddhiādivisuddhicatukkasaṅgahitamaggasampayuttā .
Samudāyesu pavattā samaññā tadekadesesupi vattatīti āha ‘‘ maggasampayuttā ’’ ti , paccekampi vā sammādiṭṭhiādīnaṃ maggasamaññāti katvā evaṃ vuttaṃ .
Dhammanānattābhāvepi
M2.78 padatthanānattamattena dukkaravacanaṃ hotīti vuttaṃ ‘‘ atthato panesā lokiyalokuttarāvā ’’ ti .Āsavavippayuttasāsavadukādīsupi vippayuttatādiggahaṇameva viseso , atthato lokiyalokuttarāva paññāti āha ‘‘ eseva nayo ’’ ti .
Ādi -saddena oghanīyaoghavippayuttaoghanīyādidukānaṃ saṅgaho daṭṭhabbo .
Paṭhamajjhānikāni cattāri maggacittāni , tathā dutiyādijjhānikāni cāti evaṃ soḷasasu maggacittesu .
Vipassanāpaññāya idha adhippetattā mahaggatapaññā na gahitā .
427. Attano cintāvasenāti tassa tassa anavajjassa atthassa sādhane paropadesena vinā
V2.74 attano upāyacintāvaseneva .Sutavasenāti yathāsutassa paropadesassa vasena .
Yathā tathā vāti parato upadesaṃ sutvā vā asutvā vā sayameva bhāvanaṃ anuyuñjantassa .
‘‘ Appanāppattā ’’ ti idaṃ sikhāppattabhāvanāmayaṃ dassetuṃ vuttaṃ , na pana ‘‘ appanāppattāva bhāvanāmayā ’’ ti .
Yogavihitesūti paññāvihitesu paññāpariṇāmitesu upāyasampāditesu .
Kammāyatanesūti ettha kammameva kammāyatanaṃ , kammañca taṃ āyatanañca ājīvānanti vā kammāyatanaṃ .
Esa nayo sippāyatanesupi .
Tattha duvidhaṃ kammaṃ hīnañca vaḍḍhakīkammādi , ukkaṭṭhañca kasivāṇijādi .
Sippampi duvidhaṃ hīnañca naḷakārasippādi , ukkaṭṭhañca muddāgaṇanādi .
Vijjāva vijjāṭṭhānaṃ .
Taṃ dhammikameva nāgamaṇḍalaparittaphudhamanakamantasadisaṃ veditabbaṃ .
Tāni panetāni ekacce paṇḍitā bodhisattasadisā manussānaṃ phāsuvihāraṃ ākaṅkhantā neva aññehi kariyamānāni passanti , na vā katāni uggaṇhanti , na kathentānaṃ suṇanti .
Atha kho attano dhammatāya cintāya karonti , paññavantehi attano dhammatāya cintāya katānipi aññehi uggaṇhitvā karontehi katasadisāneva honti .
Kammassakatan ti ‘‘ idaṃ kammaṃ sattānaṃ sakaṃ , idaṃ no sakan ’’ ti evaṃ jānanañāṇaṃ .
Saccānulomikan ti vipassanāñāṇaṃ .
Taṃ hi saccapaṭivedhassa anulomanato ‘‘ saccānulomikan ’’ ti vuccati .
Idānissa pavattanākāraṃ dassetuṃ ‘‘ rūpaṃ aniccanti vā ’’ tiādi vuttaṃ .
Tattha vā -saddena aniyamatthena dukkhānattalakkhaṇānipi
M2.79 gahitānevāti daṭṭhabbaṃ nānantariyakabhāvato .
Yaṃ hi aniccaṃ , taṃ dukkhaṃ .
Yaṃ dukkhaṃ , tadanattāti .
Yaṃ evarūpin ti yaṃ evaṃ heṭṭhā niddiṭṭhasabhāvaṃ .
Anulomikaṃ khantin tiādīni paññāvevacanāni .
Sā hi heṭṭhā vuttānaṃ kammāyatanādīnaṃ apaccanīkadassanena anulomanato , tathā sattānaṃ hitacariyāya maggasaccassa , paramatthasaccassa , nibbānassa ca avilomanato anulometīti anulomikā .
Sabbānipi etāni kāraṇāni khamati daṭṭhuṃ sakkotīti khanti .
Passatīti diṭṭhi .
Rocetīti ruci .
Munātīti muti .
Pekkhatīti pekkhā .
Te ca kammāyatanādayo dhammā etāya nijjhāyamānā nijjhānaṃ khamantīti dhammanijjhānakhanti .
Parato asutvā paṭilabhatīti aññassa upadesavacanaṃ asutvā sayameva cintento paṭilabhati .
Ayaṃ vuccatīti ayaṃ cintāmayā paññā nāma vuccati .
Sā panesā abhiññātānaṃ bodhisattānameva uppajjati .
TatthāpiV2.75 saccānulomikañāṇaṃ dvinnaṃyeva bodhisattānaṃ antimabhavikānaṃ , sesapaññā sabbesampi pūritapāramīnaṃ mahāpaññānaṃ uppajjati .
Parato sutvā paṭilabhatīti kammāyatanādīni parena kariyamānāni vā katāni vā disvāpi parassa kathayamānassa vacanaṃ sutvāpi ācariyasantike uggahetvāpi paṭiladdhā sabbā parato sutvāva paṭiladdhā nāmāti veditabbā .Samāpannassāti samāpattisamaṅgissa , nidassanamattañcetaṃ .
Vipassanāmaggapaññā idha ‘‘ bhāvanāmayā paññā ’’ ti adhippetā .
Sāti ‘‘ parittārammaṇā mahaggatārammaṇā ’’ ti ( vibha .753) vuttapaññā .
Lokiyavipassanāti lokiyavipassanāpaññā .
Sā lokuttaravipassanāti yā nibbānaṃ ārabbha pavattā appamāṇārammaṇā paññā vuttā , sā lokuttaravipassanāti maggapaññaṃ sandhāyāha .
Sā hi saṅkhārānaṃ aniccatādiṃ agaṇhantīpi vipassanākiccapāripūriyā , nibbānassa vā tathalakkhaṇaṃ visesato passatīti vipassanāti vuccati .
Gotrabhuñāṇaṃ pana kiñcāpi appamāṇārammaṇaṃ , maggassa pana āvajjanaṭṭhāniyattā na vipassanāvohāraṃ labhati .
Ayanti etāya sampattiyoti āyo , vuddhi .
Tattha kosallan ti tasmiṃ anatthahāniatthuppattilakkhaṇe āye kosallaṃ kusalatā nipuṇatā .
Taṃ
M2.80 pana ekantikaṃ āyakosallaṃ pāḷivaseneva dassetuṃ ‘‘ ime dhamme ’’ tiādi vuttaṃ .
Tattha idaṃ vuccatīti yā imesaṃ akusaladhammānaṃ anuppattipahānesu , kusaladhammānañca uppattiṭṭhitīsu paññā , idaṃ āyakosallaṃ nāmāti vuccati .Vuddhilakkhaṇā āyato apetattā apāyo , avuddhi .
Tattha kosallan ti tasmiṃ atthahānianatthuppattilakkhaṇe apāye kosallaṃ kusalatā apāyakosallaṃ .
Tampi pāḷivaseneva dassetuṃ ‘‘ ime dhamme ’’ tiādi vuttaṃ .
Tattha idaṃ vuccatīti yā imesaṃ kusaladhammānaṃ anuppajjananirujjhanesu , akusaladhammānaṃ vā uppattiṭṭhitīsu paññā , idaṃ apāyakosallaṃ nāmāti vuccati .
Āyakosallaṃ tāva paññā hotu , apāyakosallaṃ kathaṃ paññā nāma jātāti ?
Evaṃ maññati ‘‘ apāyuppādanasamatthatā apāyakosallaṃ nāma siyā ’’ ti , taṃ pana tassa matimattaṃ .
Kasmā ?
Paññavā eva hi ‘‘ mayhaṃ evaṃ manasi karoto anuppannā kusalā dhammā nuppajjanti , uppannā
V2.76 nirujjhanti .
Anuppannā akusalā dhammā uppajjanti , uppannā pavaḍḍhantī ’’ ti pajānāti , so evaṃ ñatvā anuppanne akusale na uppādeti , uppanne pajahati .
Anuppanne kusale uppādeti , uppanne bhāvanāpāripūriṃ pāpeti .
Evaṃ apāyakosallampi paññā evāti .Sabbatthāti sabbesu .
Tesaṃ tesaṃ dhammānan ti sattānaṃ taṃtaṃhitasukhadhammānaṃ .
Taṅkhaṇappavattan ti accāyike kicce vā bhaye vā uppanne tassa tikicchanatthaṃ tasmiṃyeva khaṇe pavattaṃ .
Ṭhānena uppatti etassa atthīti ṭhānuppattikaṃ , ṭhānaso eva uppajjanakaṃ .
Tatrupāyāti tatra tatra karaṇīye upāyabhūtā .
Gahetvāti ‘‘ idaṃ rūpaṃ , ettakaṃ rūpan ’’ tiādinā pariggaṇhanavasena gahetvā .
Ubhayaṃ gahetvāti ‘‘ ajjhattaṃ bahiddhā ’’ ti ubhayaṃ anupubbato pariggahetvā .
Atha vā ‘‘ yaṃ kiñci samudayadhammaṃ , sabbaṃ taṃ nirodhadhamman ’’ ti ekappahāreneva sabbepi pañcakkhandhe avibhāgena pariggahetvā .
Ayaṃ pana tikkhavipassakassa mahāpuññassa bhikkhuno vipassanābhiniveso .
428. Dukkhasaccaṃ ārabbhāti dukkhasaccaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā , tappaṭicchādakasammohavidhaṃsanavasena ca pavattaṃ ñāṇaṃ dukkhe ñāṇaṃ .
Dukkhasamudayaṃ ārabbhāti
M2.81 etthāpi eseva nayo .
Tathā sesapadadvayepi .
Paccavekkhaṇañāṇaṃ hi catusaccaṃ ārabbha pavattañāṇaṃ nāma , tatiyaṃ pana maggañāṇaṃ , itarasaccāni vipassanāñāṇanti pākaṭameva .‘‘ Atthādīsu pabhedagatāni ñāṇānī ’’ ti saṅkhepena vuttamatthaṃ pāḷivaseneva vivarituṃ ‘‘ vuttañhetan ’’ tiādi vuttaṃ .
Tattha atthe ñāṇaṃ atthapaṭisambhidāti yaṃ atthappabhedassa sallakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ atthe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ , ayaṃ atthapaṭisambhidā nāma .
Sesapadesupi eseva nayo .
Dhammappabhedassa hi sallakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ dhamme pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ dhammapaṭisambhidā .
Niruttippabhedassa sallakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ niruttābhilāpe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidā .
Paṭibhānappabhedassa sallakkhaṇavibhāvanavavatthānakaraṇasamatthaṃ paṭibhāne pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ paṭibhānapaṭisambhidā .
Niruttipaṭibhānappabhedā tabbisayānaṃ atthādīnaṃ paccayuppannatādibhedehi bhinditvā veditabbā .
Nibbānampi
V2.77 sampāpakahetuanusārena arīyati , adhigammatīti attho .
‘‘ Yaṃ kiñci paccayasambhūtan ’’ ti etena saccahetudhammapaccayākāravāresu āgatāni dukkhādīni gahitāni .
Saccapaccayākāravāresu nibbānaṃ , pariyattivāre bhāsitattho , abhidhammabhājanīye vipāko , kiriyā cāti evaṃ pāḷiyaṃ vuttānaṃ eva vasena pañca atthā veditabbā .
Dahatīti vidahati , nibbattakahetuādīnaṃ sādhāraṇametaṃ nibbacanaṃ .
Tadatthaṃ pana vibhāvetuṃ ‘‘ pavatteti vā sampāpuṇituṃ vā detī ’’ ti vuttaṃ .
Tesu purimo attho maggavajjesu daṭṭhabbo .
Bhāsitampi hi avabodhanavasena atthaṃ pavatteti , maggo pana nibbānaṃ pāpetīti tasmiṃ pacchimo attho .
Nibbānaṃ hi pattabbo attho , bhāsitattho ñāpetabbo attho , itaro nibbattetabbo atthoti evaṃ tividho hoti .
‘‘ Yo koci phalanibbattako hetū ’’ ti etena saccahetudhammapaccayākāravāresu āgatāni samudayādīni gahitāni , saccapaccayākāravāresu maggo , pariyattivāre bhāsitaṃ , abhidhammabhājanīye kusalākusalanti evaṃ pāḷiyaṃ vuttānaṃ eva vasena pañca dhammā veditabbā .
TatthaM2.82 maggo sampāpako , bhāsitaṃ ñāpako , itaraṃ nibbattakoti evaṃ tividho hetu veditabbo .
Ettha ca kiriyānaṃ avipākatāya dhammabhāvo na vutto .
Yadi evaṃ vipākā na hontīti atthabhāvopi na vattabbo ?
Na , paccayuppannabhāvato .
Evaṃ sati kusalākusalānampi atthabhāvo āpajjatīti ce ?
Nāyaṃ doso appaṭisiddhattā .
Vipākassa pana padhānahetutāya pākaṭabhāvato dhammabhāvo eva tesaṃ vutto .
Kiriyānaṃ paccayabhāvato dhammabhāvo āpajjatīti ce ?
Nāyaṃ doso appaṭisiddhattā .
Kammaphalasambandhassa pana hetubhāvassābhāvato dhammabhāvo na vutto .
Apica ‘‘ ayaṃ imassa paccayo , ayaṃ paccayuppanno ’’ ti etaṃ bhedamakatvā kevalaṃ kusalākusale , vipākakiriyādhamme ca paccavekkhantassa dhammatthapaṭisambhidā hontīti tesaṃ atthadhammatā na vuttāti daṭṭhabbaṃ .
Ayameva hi atthoti yvāyaṃ atthadhammānaṃ pañcadhā vibhajanavasena attho vutto , ayameva abhidhamme vibhajitvā dassitoti sambandho .‘‘ Dhammaniruttābhilāpe ’’ ti ettha dhamma-saddo sabhāvavācakoti katvā āha ‘‘ sabhāvaniruttī ’’ ti , aviparītaniruttīti attho .
Tenāha ‘‘ abyabhicārī vohāro ’’ ti , tassa tassa atthassa bodhane paṭiniyatasambandho saddavohāroti attho .
Tadabhilāpeti tassa sabhāvaniruttisaññitassa
V2.78 abyabhicārivohārassa abhilāpane .
Sā panāyaṃ sabhāvanirutti māgadhabhāsā .
Atthato nāmapaññattīti ācariyā .
Apare pana yadi sabhāvanirutti paññattisabhāvā , evaṃ sati paññatti abhilapitabbā , na vacananti āpajjati .
Na ca vacanato aññaṃ abhilapitabbaṃ uccāretabbaṃ atthi .
Atha phassādivacanehi bodhetabbaṃ abhilapitabbaṃ , evañca sati atthadhammānampi bodhetabbattā tesampi niruttibhāvo āpajjati .
Phassoti ca sabhāvanirutti , phassaṃ phassāti na sabhāvaniruttīti dassitovāyamattho .
Na ca avacanaṃ evaṃpakāraṃ atthi .
Tasmā vacanabhūtāya eva tassā sabhāvaniruttiyā abhilāpe uccāraṇeti attho daṭṭhabbo .
Taṃ sabhāvaniruttisaddaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā paccavekkhantassa tasmiṃ sabhāvaniruttābhilāpe pabhedagataṃ ñāṇaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidā ,‘‘ evamayaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidā saddārammaṇāM2.83 nāma jātā , na paññattiārammaṇā ’’ ti ( vibha . aṭṭha .718) ca aṭṭhakathāyaṃ vuttattā niruttisaddārammaṇāya sotaviññāṇavīthiyā parato manodvāre niruttipaṭisambhidā pavattatīti vadanti .
‘‘ Niruttipaṭisambhidā paccuppannārammaṇā ’’ ti ( vibha .749) ca vacanasaddaṃ gahetvā pacchā jānanaṃ sandhāya vuttanti .
Evaṃ pana aññasmiṃ paccuppannārammaṇe aññaṃ paccuppannārammaṇaṃ vuttanti āpajjati .
Yathā pana dibbasotañāṇaṃ manussādisaddabhedanicchayassa paccayabhūtaṃ taṃtaṃsaddavibhāvakaṃ , evaṃ sabhāvāsabhāvaniruttinicchayassa paccayabhūtaṃ paccuppannasabhāvaniruttisaddārammaṇaṃ taṃvibhāvakaṃ ñāṇaṃ niruttipaṭisambhidāti vuccamāne na koci pāḷivirodho .
‘‘ Taṃ sabhāvaniruttisaddaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā paccavekkhantassā ’’ ti ca ‘‘ paccuppannasaddārammaṇaṃ paccavekkhaṇaṃ pavattentassā ’’ ti na nasakkā vattuṃ .
Tañhi ñāṇaṃ sabhāvaniruttiṃ vibhāventameva taṃtaṃsaddapaccavekkhaṇānantaraṃ taṃtaṃpabhedanicchayahetubhāvato niruttiṃ bhindantaṃ paṭivijjhantameva uppajjatīti pabhedagatampi hotīti .Sabbattha ñāṇan ti sabbasmiṃ visaye ñāṇaṃ , sabbampi ñāṇanti adhippāyo .
Tenāha ‘‘ ñāṇārammaṇaṃ ñāṇan ’’ ti .
Sabbatthāti vā sabbesu atthādīsu , tīsu , catūsupi vā pavattattā , kusalakiriyābhūtāya paṭibhānapaṭisambhidāya dhammatthabhāvato tīsu eva vā pavattattā ‘‘ sabbattha ñāṇan ’’ ti vuttaṃ .
Tenāha ‘‘ yathāvuttesu vā ’’ tiādi .
Tattha sagocarakiccādivasenāti sagocarassa , kiccādikassa ca vasena ‘‘ idaṃ ñāṇaṃ idaṃ nāma ārammaṇaṃ katvā pavattaṃ iminā nāma
V2.79 kiccenā ’’ ti jānanaṃ .
Ādi -saddena lakkhaṇapaccupaṭṭhānapadaṭṭhānabhūmiādīnaṃ saṅgaho .
Tenevāha ‘‘ imāni ñāṇāni idamatthajotakānī ’’ tiādi . 429. Pabhedaṃ gacchantīti anekabhedabhinnesu ārammaṇesu tesaṃ yāthāvato taṃtaṃpabhedāvabodhanasamatthataṃ upagacchanti .
Etā paṭisambhidā .
Mahāsāvakānañca asekkhabhūmiyaṃ pabhedaṃ gatāti sāmaññavidhinā dassitamatthaṃ apavādena nivattetuṃ ānandatthera -ggahaṇaṃ kataṃ .
Sekkhabhūmiyaṃ pabhedagamanaṃ appavisayaṃ , asekkhabhūmiyaṃ bahuvisayanti āha ‘‘ adhigamo nāma arahattappattī ’’ ti , sātisayaṃ vā adhigamaṃ sandhāya evaṃ vuttaṃ .
Sekkhena pattānampi hi imāsaṃ arahattappattiyā visadabhāvādhigamoti
M2.84 .
Pubbayogo viya pana arahattappatti arahatopi paṭisambhidāvisadatāya paccayo na na hotīti pañcannampi yathāyogaṃ sekkhāsekkhapaṭisambhidāvisadatāya kāraṇatā yojetabbā .Atthadhammādīnaṃ anavasesasaṅgaṇhanato buddhavacanavisayā eva pariyattiādayo dassitā .
Pāḷiyā sajjhāyo pariyāpuṇanaṃ , tadatthasavanaṃ savanaṃ , parito sabbaso ñātuṃ icchā paripucchāti āha ‘‘ pāḷiaṭṭhakathādīsu gaṇṭhipadaatthapadavinicchayakathā ’’ ti , padatthato , adhippāyato ca duviññeyyaṭṭhānaṃ vitthārato sanniṭṭhānakathāti attho .
Yassa hi padassa attho duviññeyyo , taṃ gaṇṭhipadaṃ , yassa adhippāyo duviññeyyo , taṃ atthapadaṃ .
Ādi -saddena khandhādipaṭisaṃyutte kathāmagge saṅgaṇhāti .
Bhāvanānuyogasahitaṃ gataṃ , paccāgatañca etassa atthīti gatapaccāgatiko , tassa bhāvo , tena gatapaccāgatikabhāvena .
Vasanaṭṭhānato yāva gocaragāmo , tato ca yāva vasanaṭṭhānaṃ kammaṭṭhānānuyuttoti attho .
Yāva anulomagotrabhusamīpan ti saṅkhārupekkhāñāṇamāha .
Tañhi tesaṃ samīpappavattaṃ .
Satthesūti anavajjesu sattānaṃ hitasukhāvahesu ganthesu .
Tathā sippāyatanesūti etthāpi .
Pubbakāle ekasatarājūnaṃ desabhāsā ekasatavohārā .
Dhammapade ( dha . pa .1 ādayo ) yamakavaggo opammavaggoti vadanti , mūlapaṇṇāse ( ma . ni .1.325 ādayo ;439 ādayo ) yamakavaggo opammavaggo evāti apare .
Sutapaṭibhānabahulānan ti bahussutānaṃ paṭibhānavantānaṃ .
Sabbānīti
V2.80 pubbe vuttāni pañca , pacchā vuttāni aṭṭhapi vā .Sekkhaphalavimokkhapariyosāne bhavā sekkhaphalavimokkhantikā .
Ṭhānāṭhānañāṇabalādīni sabbabuddhaguṇesu sakiccato pākaṭatarānīti vuttaṃ ‘‘ dasa balāni viyā ’’ ti , aññe vā sabbaññutaññāṇādayopi sabbe bhagavato guṇavisesā asekkhaphalavimokkhantikā eva .